Comparison of the Theories of Avicenna and Mulla Sadra on the Soul and Their Application to Roger Sperry's Experiment

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Department of Philosophy, Faculty of Theology, Payam Noor University, Tabriz, Iran Department of Psychology, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Payam Noor University, Shabestar, Iran Department of Law, Faculty of Social

2 Department of Persian Literature and Foreign Languages, Faculty of Literature and Foreign Languages, Payam Noor University, Mianeh, Iran

3 Department of Psychology, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences, Payam Noor University, Qain, Iran Department of Law, Faculty of Social Sciences, Payam Noor University, Mashhad, Iran

Abstract

Human beings and their unique characteristics have always attracted the attention of philosophers throughout history and will continue to do so. Islamic philosophers, drawing from divine sources and philosophical principles, are no exception. Two renowned Muslim philosophers, Avicenna, representing the Peripatetic school, and Mulla Sadra, the founder of Transcendent Wisdom, have offered unique perspectives on this subject. In general, in Islamic philosophy, there is no disagreement about the immortality of the soul after the body, due to the clarity of Islamic sources. Most differences of opinion relate to the qualities of the soul during human life. One of the most precise theories about the soul is Mulla Sadra's theory of the corporeality of origination and the spirituality of subsistence, which posits the gradual perfection of the soul. With the advancement of knowledge today, some findings support his view, including the issue of growth until the last moment of life in developmental psychology and Roger Sperry's experiment based on physiological psychology. However, with the specialization of human knowledge, we witness a phenomenon the famous sociologist Emile Durkheim called anomie, meaning the breakdown of the organic relationship between various branches of knowledge, necessitating interdisciplinary research. This situation has led to the assumption that empirical research is different and separate from philosophical methods. The present research, employing an interdisciplinary approach, utilizes philosophical principles and physiological psychology to attempt to prove Mulla Sadra's theory of the corporeality of origination and the spirituality of subsistence through the usual empirical method, which is Roger Sperry's experiment.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Abbasi,  H. (2018). Perpatetic Philosophy1. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in Persian)
Adamson,P.  & Benevich,F.  (2018). The thought experimental method: Avicenna’s flying man argument.  American philosophical Association. 4(2):147-164.
Ali Pour,  A.  (2021). Introductions to Neuropsychology. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in Persian)
Al-Shirazi,  S.  M.  (1981). Al-Hikmah al-Muta’aliyah fi al- Asfar al- aqliyyah al- arba’ah, vol 1. Beirut, Dar Ihya al-turath. (in Arabic)
Al-Shirazi,  S.  M.  (1999). Resaleh Shavahid Al-Rububiyah. Research: Hamed Naji Esfahani. Tehran, Hekmat press. (in Arabic)
Al-Shirazi,  S.  M.  (2009). Al-Hikmah al-Muta'aliyah fi al-Asfar al-Arba'ah, vol 1&2. Introduction, annotation & Correction: Akbar Rashad and Seyed Mohammad Khamenei. Tehran, Bonyad Hekmat Eslami Sadra press. (in Arabic)
American academy of ophthalmology (2011). Visual fields examination and interpretation. New York , OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS.
Aminian,  M.  (2016). Principles of Islamic Philosophy. Qom, Bustane ketab press. (in Persian)
Atkinson,  R.  L.  (2021). Hilgard’s introduction to psychology. Translation: Mohammad Taghi Barahini & others. Tehran, Roshd press. (in Persian)
Avicenna.  (2004). The Treatise on the soul. Introduction, annotation & Correction: Moosa Amid. Hamedan, Bu-Ali Sina University. (in Persian)
Avicenna.  (2006). The Metaphysics of Najat. Translation and Commentary: Seyyed Yahya Yasrebi. Qom, Bustane ketab press. (in Persian)
Avicenna.  (2016). Selected section of Tabi’iyat nafs . Research: Ayatollah Hasan Hasanzade Amoli. Qom, Bustane ketab press. (in Arabic)
Avicenna.  (2017) Resaleh Marefat Alnafs Natigheh va Ahvalha. York House(USA), Hindawi press. (in Arabic)
Avicenna.  (2017). Isharat va Tanbihat, vol1. Translation & commentary by: Hasan Malekshahi. Tehran, Soroush press. (in Persian)
Bhat,R.  & Rockwood,K.  (2007).  Delirium as a disorder of consciousness.  Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry.78(11):1167-1170.
Board of Authors.  (2018). General psychology. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in Persian)
Bunge,  M.  Ardila,  R.  (2021). Philosophy of Psychology. Translated by: Mohammad J.Zarean et al. Tehran, RIHU press. (in Persian)
Cash,  A.  (2016). Psychology For Dummies. Translated by: Mehdi Ghara'che Dagi. Tehran, Avand Danesh publication. (in Persian)
Copleston,  F.  C.  (2017). A History of Philosophy, vol 1. Translated by: Seyed Jalaleddin Mojtabavi. Tehran, Elmifarhangi publication. (in Persian)
Darabi, K., Hoseini Shahrudi, S. M. & Javarshekian,  A.  (2024). The Evolutionary Process of Creation from Mulla Sadra's Point of View. Two quarterly Journal of SADRĀ’I WISDOM, 12(1): 17-30.
Fakhuri,  H.  Georr,  K.   (2014). History of Philosophy in the Islamic World. Translation: Abdulhamid Ayati. Tehran, elmifarhangi publication. (in Persian)
First,  M.  (2021). Handbook of Differential Diagnosis. Translation: Mehdi Ganji. Tehran, Savalan Press. (in Persian)
 Foroughi,  M.  A.  (2016). A history of western philosophy. Tehran,  Niloufar publication. (in Persian)
Ganji,  M.  (2021). Abnormal Psychology based on DSM-5. Tehran, Savalan publication. (in Persian)
Gazzaniga, M.  (2005). Forty-five years of split-brain research and still strong.  Nature reviews neuroscience.  6(8):653-659.
Ibrahimi Dinani,  GH.  (2020). General philosophical principles in Islamic philosophy. Tehran, Institute for Humanities and Cultural studies. (in Persian)
Javadi Amoli,  A.  (1997). Rahiq makhtum- Sharh Hikmat Muta’aliyah, vol2. Qom, Esra Press. (in Persian)
Javanmard,  GH.  (2022). Physiological Psychology. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in persian)
Javanmard,  GH.  (2022). Psychology Pathological. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in persian)
Kakojoybari,  A.  Sharifi,  A.  (2022). Rehabilitation of Children with Special Needs. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in Persian)
Kalat,  J.  W.  (2021). Biological Psychology. Translated by: Yahya Seyed Mohammadi. Tehran, Ravan publication. (in Persian)
Karaji,  A.  (2017). Philosophical Terms and the Differences between Them. Qom,  Bustane ketab press. (in Persian)
Khansari,  M.  (2015). Resume de logique formelle. Tehran, University of Tehran press. (in persian)
Khansari,  M.  (2018). Formal logic. Tehran, Didar press. (in Perasian)
Le gros clark, W.E. (1942). The visual centers of the brain and their connexions.  Physiological reviews. 22(3):205-232.
Mesbah Yazdi,  M.  T.  (1987). Philosophy Education, vol 2. Tehran, Islamic Propagation Publications. (in Persian)
Mesbah Yazdi,  M.  T.  (1998). Sharh Jeld Hashtom Asfar Arba'ah, vol 2. Tehran, The imam Khomeini education & research institute. (in Persian)
Mosaei Afzali,  A.  (2012). Theology 1. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in Persian)
Muzaffar,  M.  R.  (2015). Logic. Translated by: Majid Hamidzadeh & Ensha'allah Rahmati. Tehran, Hekmat press. (in Persian)
Oboudiyat,  AA.  (2013). Introductory Philosophy Derived from the Works of Morteza Motahhari. Tehran, SAMT press. (in Persian)
Panahi Shahri,  M.  (2021). Psychology of Sensation and Perception. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in persian)
Piri,  A.  Ismyilov,  F.  (2011). A comparative study on body-soul relation in Molla Sadra and Bergson`s philosophy. Two quarterly Journal of  Religious Anthropology 8(26): 103-118. (in Persian)
Saadeghi,  A.  (2018). Comparative Philosophy. Tehran, Payame Noor University press. (in Persian)
Seligman,  ME.  P. & Rosenhan,  D. & Walker,  E.  (2014). Abnormal psychology, vol1. Translation: Reza Rostami and others. Tehran, Arjmand publication. (in Persian)
Shakibi,  Z.  Alamolhoda,  S.  A.  Peikani,  J.  (2020). Philosophy. Tehran Payame Noor University press. (in Persian)
Sperry,R.W (1968).  Hemisphere DE connection unity in conscious awareness. American psychology.  23(10):723-733.
Sperry,R.W (1975).  Left brain-Right brain. Biofeedback. 30-33 
Tabataba'I,  S.  MH. (2014 A). The Commencement of Philosophy (The translation of Bidayah al- Hikmah). Translation: Mohammad Ali Gerami. Qom, Bustane ketab press. (in Persian)
Tabataba'I,  S.  MH. (2014 B). Bidayat ul-Hikmah. Translation: Ali Shirvani. Qom, Bustane ketab press. (in Persian)
Tabataba'I,  S.  MH. (2019). Nihayat ul-Hikmah. Translation: Ali Shirvani. Qom, Bustane ketab press. (in Persian)
The Holy Qur'an
Wandell,A.B. & Dumoulins,O.S.  Brewer,A.A.(2007).  Visual Field Maps in Human Cortex.  Neuron. 56(2):366-383.
Wilson,  DH.  &  Reeves,   A.   & Gazzaninga  , M (1978). Division of the corpus callosum for uncontrollable epilepsy. Neurology, 28(7):649-53.
Zabihi,  M.  (2013). Perpatetic Philosophy. Tehran, SAMT press. (in Persian)