Study and analysis of Mohaghegh Esfahani's argument on the proof of God's existence

Document Type : Research Article

Author

theology payam nour tehran iran

Abstract

Allameh Shaykh Muhammad Husayn Gharavi, known as Muhaqqiq Isfahani and famously referred to as Kompani, is one of the prominent Neo-Sadrian philosophers who, in his work Tuhfat al-Hakim, presents an argument for the existence of God. Some scholars have interpreted this argument as a formulation of the Burhan al-Siddiqin (Proof of the Truthful), while others have likened it to Anselm’s ontological argument, even going so far as to consider Kompani the originator of the ontological proof within Islamic philosophy. This article aims to analyze the conceptual structure of his argument and demonstrate that it is founded not upon external reality, but upon the notion of the “Necessary Being” (wajib bi-dhat). Whereas the Burhan al-Siddiqin proceeds from the objective reality of existence to the necessity of a necessary existent, the ontological argument moves from the concept of existence to its actual instantiation. Kompani, relying solely on conceptual analysis and without reference to empirical reality, seeks to deduce the actual existence of God. By examining the ontological and epistemological foundations of this proof, the article reconsiders its place within the framework of Islamic philosophy and highlights its divergence from conventional formulations. It further argues that, despite its traditional appearance, Kompani’s argument embodies a novel approach to philosophical conceptualization—one that opens new horizons for understanding the relationship between concept and referent, and for rationally articulating divine existence within the Islamic philosophical tradition.

Keywords

Main Subjects


The Holy Qur’an (In Arabic)
Abudiyyat, ‘Abd al-Rasul (2007 [1386 SH]). An Introduction to the Sadrian Philosophical System. Tehran: SAMT & Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute, 1st edition. (In Persian)
Afzali, Ali M. (2007 [1386 SH]). “The Ontological Argument in the Thought of Leibniz and Muhammad Husayn Gharavi Esfahani (Kompani).” In: Transcendent Philosophy and Other Schools, Vol. 3. Edited by Ayatollah Sayyed Mohammad Khamenei. Tehran: Sadra Islamic Philosophy Foundation, 1st edition. (In Persian)
Ashtiyani, Mirza Mahdi (1993 [1372 SH]). Glosses on the Commentary of Sabzevari’s Philosophical Poem. Tehran: University of Tehran Press, 3rd edition.  (In Persian) 
Edwards, Paul (1992 [1371 SH]). Arguments for the Existence of God in Western Philosophy. Translated by Alireza Jamali-Nasab & Mohammad Mohammad-Rezaei. Qom: Islamic Propagation Office. (In Persian)
Encyclopedia of Shi‘ism (In Persian)
Gharavi Esfahani, Shaykh Muhammad Husayn (n.d.). Tuhfat al-Hakim (The Philosopher’s Gift). Qom: Al al-Bayt Publications. (In Arabic) 
Hosseini Tehrani, Sayyed Mohammad Husayn (1990 [1410 AH]). Scientific and Objective Monotheism in Philosophical and Mystical Schools. Tehran: Hikmat Publications, 1st edition. (In Persian)
Ibn Sina, Husayn ibn ‘Abdullah (1983 [1403 AH]). Al-Isharat wa al-Tanbihat (Pointers and Reminders). Qom: Daftar Nashr al-Kitab. (In Arabic)
Ibn Sina, Husayn ibn ‘Abdullah (1985 [1364 SH]). Al-Najah (The Deliverance). Tehran: Mortezavi Publications. (In Arabic)
Javadi Amoli, Abdullah (1999 [1378 SH]). Explanation of Arguments for the Existence of God. Qom: Isra Publications, 3rd edition. (In Persian)
Kompani, Shaykh Muhammad Husayn (2011 [1390 SH]). Tuhfat al-Hakim (The Philosopher’s Gift). Translated by Gholamreza Rahmani. Qom: Bustan-e-Ketab Institute, 1st edition. (In Persian)
Mar‘ashi Najafi, Sayyed Shihab al-Din (1995 [1416 AH]). Musalsalat (Chains of Transmission). Qom: Ayatollah Mar‘ashi Library Publications, 1st edition. (In Persian)
Misbah Yazdi, Mohammad-Taqi (1993 [1372 SH]). Philosophy Instruction. Tehran: Islamic Propagation Organization. (In Persian)
Mohammad Rezaei, Mohammad (2011 [1390 SH]). Modern Theology with a Comparative Approach. Qom: Ma‘aref Publishing Office. (In Persian)
Motahhari, Morteza (1982 [1361 SH]). Commentary on the Philosophical Poem. Tehran: Hikmat Publications. (In Persian)
Motlabi, Sayyed Abolhassan (September 1991 [1370 SH]). “The Stars of the Ummah: Grand Ayatollah Shaykh Muhammad Husayn Gharavi Esfahani.” Noor-e-‘Elm Journal, Issue 40. (In Persian)
Nabavian, Mohammad Mahdi (2018 [1397 SH]). Essays in Islamic Philosophy. Qom: Islamic Philosophy Publications. (In Persian)
Sabzevari, Haj Mulla Hadi (n.d.). Sharh al-Manzumeh (Commentary on the Philosophical Poem). Qom: Mostafavi Publications. (In Arabic)
Shirazi (Sadr al-Muta’allihin), Muhammad ibn Ibrahim (1966 [1386 AH]). Al-Hikmah al-Muta‘aliyah fi al-Asfar al-‘Aqliyyah al-Arba‘ah (The Transcendent Philosophy in the Four Intellectual Journeys). Qom: Al-Maktabah al-Mustafawiyyah. (In Arabic)
Shirazi (Sadr al-Muta’allihin), Muhammad ibn Ibrahim (1999 [1378 SH]). Secrets of the Verses. Qom: Habib Publications. (In Arabic)
Shirazi (Sadr al-Muta’allihin), Muhammad ibn Ibrahim (n.d.). Al-Masha‘ir (The Perceptions). Commentary by Mirza Imad al-Dawlah. Isfahan: Mahdavi Publications. (In Arabic)
Yousofian, Hassan (2011 [1390 SH]). Modern Theology. Tehran: SAMT; Qom: Imam Khomeini Educational and Research Institute, 3rd edition. (In Persian)